[Salon] Trump’s rise signals the end of US global leadership



Opinion | Trump’s rise signals the end of US global leadership

Expect greater isolationism in favour of bilateral, outcome-based deals with no more free rides for allies as Trump seeks capitulation, not cooperation

Donald Trump takes to the stage for his last rally before the presidential election, in Van Andel Arena on November 5, in Grand Rapids, Michigan. Photo: Getty Images/TNS

Donald Trump’s victory in the US presidential election ushers in an America that will swashbuckle through the world like brawny sailors on shore leave.

We can expect his administration to be an emotional whirlwind of guttural, visceral attacks hurled spontaneously, rather than four years of measured, calculated approaches anchored in deeply grounded ideas about the workings of statecraft and a rules-based international order. “America first”, he swears, is his lodestar.

His last term as president and campaign speeches this year suggest he will be unpredictable, erratic, imperial, discursive and less than coherent, with trademark chauvinism and caustic diatribes. Frequent purges of staff will leave his administration unnerved.

We can expect greater isolationism in favour of bilateral, outcome-based deals that promise more than they deliver. No more free rides for allies. Personal vendettas will be fused with nationalism. Facts will become malleable artifices. His wrath will know few bounds, and his arsenal will use sticks, not carrots. He will seek capitulation not cooperation. His rise signals the end of America’s global leadership after World War II.

The election’s decisive results will embolden him with support from the Republican-controlled Senate and seemingly the House of Representatives. The more extreme voices in his camp will dominate. His dark world view is a Dante-esque inferno – ruthless titans battle amid legions of enemies.

To survive, America must be all guile and guts, and relentless in its offence. Friends can quickly become foes.

Donald Trump secures enough Electoral College votes to win 2024 US presidential election
Trump’s immediate agenda is grandiose: show China America is in charge, end Russia’s war against Ukraine within 24 hours of taking office, and bring peace to the Middle East.
Trump has vowed to impose tariffs of at least 60 per cent on Chinese imports and to terminate China’s most favoured nation trading status. Tariff is “the most beautiful word in the dictionary”, he has said. Last year, Chinese companies exported US$500 billion in goods to the United States, about 15 per cent of the value of all its exports.
He may tighten export controls on advanced technologies. The day after his victory, the offshore yuan fell by as much as 1.3 per cent against the US dollar, the largest one-day drop since October 2022. Greater volatility will plague China’s markets during his term.

Given his animosity towards multilateralism, expect him to move away from President Joe Biden’s security partnerships with Asian countries to contain China. He is likely to continue military aid for Taiwan if Taipei ramps up military spending and plans to counter any threat from Beijing to blockade Taiwan with paralysing tariffs.

But tariffs and other trade barriers have significant consequences that underscore the interdependence of the world’s two largest economies. For Tesla, run by key Trump supporter Elon Musk, China accounted for half of its vehicle sales and a fifth of its production capacity – the Shanghai Gigafactory is Tesla’s largest manufacturing plant.
The Tesla Gigafactory in Lingang, Shanghai, seen on September 26, 2023. Photo: AP
The Tesla Gigafactory in Lingang, Shanghai, seen on September 26, 2023. Photo: AP

Similar entanglements were reflected in the latest US corporate reports, with performance in China weighing heavily on earnings trajectories. DuPont, for instance, said quarterly sales for its semiconductor business jumped by more than 20 per cent due largely to China’s growing demand.

US semiconductor companies will struggle if China cuts off access to critical minerals. Trump will find that such adverse consequences will undercut the economic boom he believes protectionism will fuel. Voters see him as more capable of running the economy than Kamala Harris. He may quickly find opinions souring as the fallout hits.

To end the Ukraine war, Trump vowed to act even before he is sworn in on January 20. He has said he would settle it in a day and before entering the White House. Meanwhile, he has criticised Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky’s repeated requests for US aid, saying: “It never ends.” He also said he has warned Russian President Vladimir Putin that “if you go after Ukraine, I am going to hit you so hard, you’re not even going to believe it. I’m going to hit you right in the middle of fricking Moscow”.

Former security advisers to Trump advocate tying weapons for Ukraine with Zelensky’s commitment to talk to Moscow. Russia could be enticed to negotiate if Ukraine’s Nato entry is delayed. The current front lines could serve as a starting point to negotiate new boundaries, the aides argue.
That leaves open the question of Trump’s relationship with Putin, one that has US allies in Europe unsettled. He has warned fellow members of Nato that unless they meet defence spending obligations, the US would not abide by the mutual defence pact to protect them from Russia’s attacks. “I would not protect you,” he said in February. “In fact, I would encourage them [Russia] to do whatever the hell they want.”
Another Trump priority is peace in the Middle East. “Get it over with and let’s get back to peace and stop killing people,” he said in April. Yet he appears to back Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu’s hardline policies. Trump has no vision of a peace deal.

Trump’s campaign rhetoric suggests his second term will be much like his first, only swayed by more extreme voices.

James David Spellman, a graduate of Oxford University, is principal of Strategic Communications LLC, a consulting firm based in Washington, DC.


This archive was generated by a fusion of Pipermail (Mailman edition) and MHonArc.